ecommerce

Australians will let AI choose. They won't let it pay.

John Dwyer 6 min read

Australian shoppers have already worked out what they want AI to do for them, and what they don’t. They are happy to let an agent compare products, check prices and narrow the list. They are not handing over the credit card. The gap between those two things is much wider than most of the coverage suggests, and it points somewhere useful if you sell online. A lot of merchant effort right now is going into the half that customers are most reluctant about.

62%
of Australians are open to an AI agent helping them decide
14%
trust an AI agent to actually place the order
42%
of merchants are already testing agentic checkout

Where shoppers have drawn the line

62% of Australian consumers are open to an AI agent helping them make purchasing decisions, according to the commercetools Agentic Commerce Radar, across everyday categories like household items, subscriptions, gifts and travel bookings.

Then the numbers fall off a cliff. In the same research, 65% of consumers trust AI to compare prices for them. Only 14% trust it to place the order.

People want the research done. They want to keep the payment.

What consumers trust an AI shopping agent to do

What this means for you Shoppers are already comfortable letting AI shortlist and compare. The moment money moves, almost all of that comfort disappears.

Why this matters

This is the single most useful number in the current research. It tells you that the commercial opportunity right now sits in being found and recommended, not in automating the transaction. Discovery is live today. Autonomous checkout is a bet on behaviour that has not shifted yet.

Merchants are building the other half

Checkout.com surveyed merchants and consumers across six markets. 42% of merchants are already testing agentic commerce. 72% agree consumers will adopt agent-led shopping faster than most merchants are ready for.

On the consumer side, 33% expect at least 10% of their purchases to be AI-driven within a year. So the demand is real and it is arriving quickly.

But a lot of that merchant investment is going into autonomous checkout, which is exactly the part shoppers are most reluctant about. One in four say they will never delegate a purchase to AI. 27% trust no organisation at all to run a shopping agent for them.

Agentic commerce readiness: merchants and consumers

What this means for you Merchants can see the wave coming. The risk is spending the budget on the transaction when customers are only ready for the recommendation.

Why this matters

Notice that the highest number here is merchant anxiety rather than merchant capability. 72% expect to be outpaced, but only 42% are testing anything. That gap usually gets filled with a platform purchase. It is worth being sure the problem is a platform problem first.

What people want before they hand over a card

Checkout.com also asked consumers what would make them comfortable delegating spend. The answers came back almost level: spending caps, the ability to revoke permission instantly, and easy cancellation.

No single feature wins, which is the finding. People want control, and they want it visible.

What consumers say they need before delegating spend

What this means for you Three answers within two points of each other. Customers are not asking for one clever feature, they are asking to stay in charge.

Why this matters

When preferences come back this flat, it usually means the underlying need is singular even though the survey split it three ways. The need here is reversibility. Anything that lets a customer cap, pause or undo an agent's authority is doing the same job.

The move I’d make first

The part of this that is already happening is discovery. AI is comparing products right now and recommending some of them. That runs on whatever your site publishes: product data, pricing, stock, reviews, delivery terms.

If that information is thin, stale or contradicts itself, the agent skips you and recommends someone clearer. No checkout protocol required, and no new platform to buy.

So before anyone builds agentic checkout, get the basics machine readable:

  • Product feeds that are accurate and actually current, not a quarterly export
  • Structured data that matches what a human sees on the page, including price and availability
  • Real stock and delivery information, not “contact us”
  • Reviews and specifications a machine can parse rather than an image of a spec table
  • Consistent product naming across your site, your feed and your marketplace listings

That is unglamorous work. It is also the work that pays off whether agentic checkout arrives next year or in five, because the same clean data feeds Google Shopping, your own search, and every comparison tool in between.

If your product data is already in decent shape, this may be a small job. We will tell you that rather than turn it into a project.

Where this data comes from

Every figure in this post was checked against the original source rather than a summary of it.

Talk to us

Book your discovery call

Pick a time that suits you and we will have a straight conversation about where your business is at and whether we can help. No obligation, no pitch.

  • No obligation A straight chat about where your business is at. No pitch deck, no pressure to sign anything.
  • Fifteen focused minutes We keep it tight and respect your time, so you get value even from a short call.
  • Clear next steps You leave with at least one practical idea you can act on, whether or not we work together.

Your consultation will be with

John Dwyer, Smashed Avo John Dwyer Fractional Digital Strategist

Prefer to contact us directly?

Call, email or use the contact page.